SCJ establishes the sentence must be in accordance with the committed crime, legal parameters, and based on provided evidence

The Criminal Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice (SCJ) established the legal precedent that the decision not to accept a mitigating circumstance in sentencing is a discretionary power that cannot be considered an obligation imposed on the judge. 

By judgment No. SCJ-SS-22-0581 In a decision dated June 30, 2022, the aforementioned Chamber also reaffirmed its position that the sentence must be commensurate with the crime committed, fall within the legal parameters, and be duly justified based on the evidence presented, as provided for in Article 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. 

“In this case, there is not the slightest mitigating factor, excuse, or circumstance that could be taken into consideration in favor of the defendant to mitigate (moderate) the penalty, since the circumstances of the act committed and proven against the appellant do not minimize, diminish, or reduce the gravity and magnitude of the crime he committed and for which he was tried and convicted, the offense in question being, ”As has been established, for aggravated robbery and use of a knife," the ruling states. 

In this regard, the judges of the Second Chamber—Francisco Antonio Jerez Mena, who presides over it, Fran Euclides Soto Sánchez, and María Garabito Ramírez—dismissed the appeal filed against the judgment No. 502-01-2021-SSEN-00045, handed down by the Third Chamber of the Criminal Division of the National District Court of Appeals, upholding the five-year prison sentence for aggravated robbery.  

The defendant’s legal defense sought to have the mitigating circumstance of conditional suspension of the sentence, as established in Article 341 of the law, applied to him, a request that was rejected by the trial judges; their ruling, which was upheld by the court, held that the imposition of the sentence was duly justified in accordance with Article 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.  

To access full In light of the ruling, please click the link here.

Source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *