
The Joint Chambers of the Supreme Court of Justice (SCJ) hold that when a claim regarding a contractual dispute has been tried in court and the cause of action is not dismissed, the same action may be pursued again if the debtor continues to be in breach or performs the obligation improperly.
The legal principle is set forth in Judgment No. SCJ-SR-23-0031 dated May 29, 2023, in which it explains that it is up to the trial court to decide whether the failure to pay the purchase price continues to constitute grounds for termination of the contract and, as part of its discretionary authority, to determine whether or not such termination would be legally valid.
“An argument to the contrary would be legally incorrect, insofar as a contract affected by the buyer’s failure to pay for the service rendered would create a state of legal limbo, resulting in the seller’s loss of the right to obtain payment as consideration for the item sold,” states the aforementioned ruling.
In this regard, the Joint Chambers affirm civil judgment No. 1303-2018-SSEN-00032, rendered on January 22, 2018, by the Third Chamber of the Civil and Commercial Division of the Court of Appeals of the National District, and remands it to the Second Chamber of the Civil and Commercial Division of the Court of Appeals of the same jurisdiction.
“It follows from the procedural situation outlined above that, even though the High Court overstepped its role by addressing the answer beyond the limits of its jurisdiction and procedural oversight, we have proceeded to set aside the contested judgment, adopting our own reasoning based on the interplay between the principle of res judicata and the relativity of contracts, as follows from the combined interpretation of Articles 1108, 1184, 1304, 1350, 1351, 1599, and 1654 of the Civil Code, after noting the existence of the defects alleged against the contested judgment,” explains the decision of the Joint Chambers.
The ruling was issued by Justices Luis Henry Molina Peña, Manuel R. Herrera Carbuccia, Francisco A. Jerez Mena, Fran E. Soto Sánchez, Justiniano Montero Montero, Rafael Vásquez Goico, Napoleón R. Estévez Lavandier, Moisés A. Ferrer Landrón, Francisco A. Ortega Polanco, Julio César Canó, Etanislao Rodríguez, and Arelis Ricourt.
To read the full decision, click the following link: https://poderjudicial.gob.do/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Sent.-SCJ-SR-23-00031.pdf
